Cherokee History of Civil War Appalachia
Myths abound in our understanding of American history. For example, the Civil War did not end with Robert E. Lee’s surrender at Appomattox Court House. Students of the war know that tens of thousands of Confederate soldiers remained in the field, most to be surrendered—not to Ulysses S. Grant—to William Tecumseh Sherman, whose middle name reflected his father’s admiration of the great chief of the Shawnees, “Tecumseh.” This is ironic, because the last Confederate general to surrender was Stand Watie, a chief of the Cherokee Nation. General Watie laid down his arms in the West, in present-day Oklahoma.
This touches upon another myth, that all Cherokees were expelled from the Eastern United States in the 1830s, forced to travel the “Trail of Tears” to “Indian Territory” (present-day Oklahoma). In fact, Cherokee living throughout Appalachia, especially in North Carolina, had successfully resisted forced relocation. When the Civil War came, many volunteered for military service, mostly as Confederates, recognizing an opportunity to establish a right to citizenship in a new nation, just as African Americans would argue that their wartime service for the Union should guarantee their rights as American citizens. The “Cherokee Battalion” earned a reputation as fearsome soldiers. And, as the new Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians, their leading veterans demanded citizenship and recognition.
To explore this little known but intriguing story, the Roanoke Civil War Round Table presents Dr. Stuart Marshall. Dr. Marshall will explore how Cherokees who remained in their homeland after the Trail of Tears regrouped to face the next crisis of disunion. By volunteering for Confederate military service, Cherokees hoped to strengthen their right to remain, only to suffer defeat and dispersal. But in the postwar world, Cherokee politicians crafted their own Lost Cause narratives to confront new threats of disenfranchisement.
Dr. Marshall is the postdoctoral associate at the Virginia Tech Center for Civil War Studies. His current book project, The Age of Junaluska, traces the Civil War origins of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians and their manipulation of the “Lost Cause” in struggles for citizenship and sovereignty. With colleagues at Western Carolina University, he is also working on the first volume of Eastern Cherokee Histories in Translation, which will focus on Civil War letters written in Cherokee syllabary. Marshall is also a contributor to several forthcoming edited volumes including Rethinking the ‘Indian Wars.’
Date, Time & Location of Dr. Marshall’s Talk: Tuesday, December 8, 2026 (7:00 pm), Chapel of the Residents’ Center at Friendship North, 367 Hershberger Road, Roanoke, VA, 24012. Admission $5.00 for Non-Round Table Members (and becoming a Round Table member is welcome).






